White Fragility Blog Response #4 Chapter 3
McLeod
1
Garrett McLeod
Professor Heather Stewart-Steele
ENGL-1303
28 February 2021
White
Fragility Blog Response #4 – Chapter 3
DiAngelo’s primary focus in this chapter is explaining the
complexities of how racism has adapted to the new norms of the post-Civil Rights
era, where it is not so culturally accepted to identify outrightly as a racist.
There are three aspects of our society that she points out to be the main ways
in which this adaptation has firmly established itself, the emergence of color-blind
racism, spreading of aversive racism, and continuation of the same cultural
racism that has existed since the founding of our country.
Many do not realize that the vast majority of the White
population at the time of the Civil Rights Movement, either did not support or
usually just outwardly hated Martin Luther King Jr., but since then it has become
a taboo to be against him in any shape and form. Not only that, but his very
words have been appropriated to work against his very life mission. DiAngelo
explains how King’s quote about judging a man by the content of his character
and not the color of his skin, has been hijacked for the use of the status quo.
This is the case because it is interpreted as meaning that if we ignore race
then race will cease to exist, when in reality the racial status quo is what is
supported when race is ignored in a country so deeply affected by it both past
and
McLeod
2
present. In my own life I
have come across the phenomenon of racist color-blindness. Where someone who
claims to be color-blind and therefore not racist, when confronted with an issue
connected to race will then turn the issue around like an act of mental jiu-jitsu,
and say that you are in fact the racist for pointing out that race affects
peoples lives in the first place. Color-blindness is a prime example of white
fragility, because it allows one to ignore their racial biases, while at the
same time justifying it to themselves as morally righteous even, because it is
considered anti-racist action.
Aversive racism is similar in that it helps one to
maintain a positive self-image while perpetuating the same issues as everyone
else. DiAngelo uses the example of a conversation based around moving to a black-neighborhood
that is of a low socio-economic status. Because of how racism has held down
African Americans from accumulating inter-generational wealth in myriad ways,
it is the case that majority African American neighborhoods tend to be of a lower
economic status, which coincides with crime no matter the race. So, this puts people
who are unaware of that context, because it has served the status quo to not
make this information mainstream, into a really difficult position when they
see the undeniable fact that African American neighborhoods tend to have more
crime. It is truly insidious, because well-meaning people who do not know the
whole context because of propaganda, or will not accept it because of their
white fragility, are left with cognitive dissonance. Because they believe simultaneously
that any individual can get ahead in our society, and that African Americans
are not lesser than them, but then African American individuals still tend to
be of a lower socio-economic status, so what are they supposed to make of all
this?
Color blindness is something I deal with so much whenever I have to talk about the topic of racism to my fellow white friends. As you mentioned, whenever i try to bring the topic up of how maybe they are being racist or saying slightly racist things, they will turn the whole conversation around and direct it at me being the bad person and the racist one. It is honestly so mind boggling to me that people cannot understand that being white allows for so much more freedom than being colored. The mental jui-jitsu is something I think white people have developed over the years to try and protect themselves. They never want to be the one under attack in a conversation and are always taking the defensive side in uncomfortable topics such as racism. I think it has to due with the fact that white people have never been the ones under attack and when it is them they wont ever accept it. I couldn't agree with you more in your last paragraph about generation wealth. It is something I have brought up previously when discussing why people of color have such different socioeconomics status compared to white people. The fact that they were never born into wealth is a huge reason as to why people of color tend to live in poorer neighborhoods with more crime. It inevitable within the society we live in. More funding needs to be allocated to these areas in order for us to see any difference.
ReplyDeleteDuring the protests sparked by the murder of George Floyd this past summer we clearly saw 2 types of people emerge from it. The people supporting Black Lives Matter and people saying all lives matter. This is pure color blindness. We often heard people saying "I'm not racist, I don't see color", but that is the problem. We want you to see our color. If you don't see our color then you also don't see the oppression we, people of color face. I say this all to agree with your statement of colorblindness being a prime example of white fragility. Acknowledging the issue as hand is just the start.
ReplyDeleteThe topic of socio-economic status that you brought up in your last paragraph is something that I have not always known. Being a person of color and growing up in a white neighborhood, I was not presented with the same life experiences as my cousins who grew up in a predominately colored neighborhood. Growing up, I just thought they made bad decisions and had the same opportunities as me, but this can't be farther from the truth. I was given the upper hand compared to them. They were surrounded by violence and crime, whereas I was in an environment that was setting me up for success. My siblings and I have all received college degrees and most of my cousins who grew up in predominately colored neighborhoods have been to jail. I can clearly see the issue and the problem. Generational wealth is something that can't be ignored.